S&W 586 vs 686: A practical comparison for Australia

The Smith & Wesson Model 586 and Model 686 are both six-shot .357 Magnum revolvers built on S&W's L-frame, yet they serve different priorities. The 586 is generally the simpler, fixed-sight revolver, while the 686 is the more adjustable and target-oriented member of the family. For Australian shooters, that difference can matter more than the cylinder capacity they share.

The L-frame provides a full-size grip and a substantial six-shooter platform for .357 Magnum, .357 and .38 Special ammunition where those loads are approved for the particular firearm. Both have double-action/single-action operation, a swing-out cylinder and a broad family of factory accessories. “Six-shooter” is familiar language around Australian clubs, although 686 variants can differ noticeably in barrel length, weight and sight arrangement.

The decision is therefore less about whether one model is suitable and more about which layout suits the shooter. Sights, muzzle weight, holster availability, condition and local ownership rules should all be considered, especially when buying from an overseas retailer such as Wesson Arms.

Shared foundations and practical differences

Both revolvers sit in the same broad size and performance class. Their common features make either one familiar to a shooter who has handled an S&W L-frame revolver before.

The differences are more visible in the details that affect handling and use.

Neither name identifies one fixed specification. A short-barrelled 686 and a longer 586 can differ in feel, so comparing the exact model number is more useful than treating the labels as complete descriptions.

Barrel length, sights and handling

Sights are the clearest dividing line. A standard 586's integral sights are simple, uncluttered and difficult to knock out of alignment, which can suit a working revolver or a shooter who wants fewer adjustable components. A 686's adjustable rear sight is more useful when sight picture and precise zeroing are priorities, especially for target work at Bisley or a club range.

Barrel length changes balance more noticeably than it changes practical performance. Standard and short configurations commonly use barrels around 4⅛ to 5 inches, while the 686 is also offered in longer versions. The added length can make the revolver steadier and, in some configurations, slightly reduce muzzle rise. It also increases the overall footprint and can affect what fits in a holster or vehicle.

Controls and grip dimensions remain recognisably L-frame, but sight height, barrel profile and underlug arrangement can alter how the revolver sits in the hand. A shooter trying an L-frame for the first time should compare actual variants rather than assume every 586 and 686 has the same dimensions.

Recoil control and shooting accuracy

Both revolvers fire .357 Magnum, so neither offers a soft-shooting advantage inherent to its model. The practical differences come from total weight, the balance ahead of the cylinder and the barrel's ability to absorb recoil. Many longer-barrelled 686 configurations feel more settled, while compact 586s can feel lively in the hand.

Adjustable sights on a 686 can help a shooter establish a consistent sight picture. That does not automatically make the 686 more accurate than a 586: fixed sights can produce excellent results, and accuracy also depends on the ammunition, the firearm's condition, mounting and the shooter's technique. Barrel length alone cannot compensate for poor alignment or an inconsistent hold.

For target use, a 686 with a longer barrel and adjustable sights is often the more flexible choice. For general handling, an owner who values simplicity, compactness and a clean sight picture may prefer the 586. At any Australian range, formal training, eye and hearing protection, and compliance with the current manual remain basic requirements.

Finish, durability and service

Many 586s are supplied in blued steel, while the 686 is particularly well known in stainless steel, although both families include different finishes and special editions. Coastal shooters around Sydney, the Gold Coast or Perth should still treat any firearm as vulnerable to salt-laden air, while dust and heat inland demand routine care. Stainless steel simplifies corrosion control but does not make a revolver maintenance-free.

The adjustable sights on a 686 introduce components that need sensible care and occasional checking. Fixed sights on a 586 have fewer adjustment points, while the frame, cylinder and locking system still require regular inspection and cleaning under the manufacturer's guidance. A qualified gunsmith is the right home for uncertain reliability or sight problems.

Accessory choices also reflect the model. Grips, holsters, lights and mounting systems must suit the exact barrel, underlug and rail arrangement. Gun shops in Melbourne, Sydney, Brisbane, Perth and Adelaide carry many L-frame accessories, but a generic “L-frame holster” is rarely the right description when frame and barrel dimensions vary.

Buying and using an L-frame in Australia

Australia's firearm market is tightly regulated. A firearm licence is administered through state and territory authorities, and the category held by the buyer determines what can be acquired. Secure storage, transport and, in some jurisdictions, ammunition storage have their own rules. Private transfers commonly require approval or a permit, including transactions arranged through a gun show, so buyers should check their local authority before agreeing to a sale.

Wesson Arms lists 586 and 686 models, Performance Center variants and discounted blemished units, and promotes worldwide shipping. For Australia, overseas availability does not remove Australian Border Force, licensing or transport requirements. The retailer should confirm that the exact model can be supplied to the destination, that the buyer has the appropriate authority, and what freight arrangements apply. A blemished listing should also identify the cosmetic issue and the inspection or warranty terms; a finish mark does not by itself describe mechanical condition.

Ammunition is widely available in .357 Magnum and .38 Special through licensed gun shops, although choice and pricing in Australian dollars can vary sharply between metropolitan and regional areas. Buyers around Melbourne and Sydney usually have more shops and brands to compare, while shooters in regional Victoria, Western Australia or Queensland may have fewer suppliers and longer gaps between them. The Bisley shooting complex near Canberra and many local club ranges provide the settings where these differences are most useful in practice.

These conditions reward a patient purchase. Checking the exact model number, barrel length, sight configuration, cylinder condition, included accessories and return terms can prevent a discounted price from becoming an expensive mismatch. Australian shooters often call a revolver a “six-gun” as readily as a “six-shooter”; regardless of the term, serial number, condition and legal eligibility should be verified before ownership changes.

Choosing the revolver that suits the job

The 586 makes the most sense for a shooter seeking a straightforward .357 Magnum revolver with fixed sights, a relatively compact profile and minimal sight hardware. It is a practical choice when simplicity, clean handling and lower purchase complexity matter more than adjustable sighting or a broad choice of barrel lengths.

The 686 is generally the stronger option for target-oriented use, adjustable sights, longer barrel configurations and a wider selection of specialist variants. Its extra front-end weight can also improve perceived control with the powerful .357 cartridge. A specific rail-equipped or Performance Center 686 may serve a particular purpose, but those features are optional rather than defining every model.

The lasting distinction is simple: the 586 centres on a compact, fixed-sight L-frame six-shooter, while the 686 centres on adjustability and choice. The best decision is the exact configuration that fits the shooter, the available accessories and Australian ownership requirements, not the model with the longer specification list.